This AI prompt scores your options against what matters to you, then picks one and shows the math. It works for contractor quotes, internet plans, job offers or any choice where the details are written down.
It asks 3 questions first, builds a scorecard from your answers and checks it with you before it scores anything.
Why AI gives you pros and cons instead of a pick
Ask AI which option is best and it tends to give you balance instead. You get pros and cons for every option, a note that each one has a problem, and no pick.
That happens because it doesn’t know what matters most to you, so it stays neutral. The way around it is to tell it first. Once it knows your non-negotiables and your priorities, it has a way to rank the options, and it can name a winner.
This prompt is a weighted decision matrix. Each option gets a score from 1 to 5 on 5 things you care about, the important things count for more, and the highest total wins. If you want AI to argue with the option you’re already leaning toward, the hard decision prompt does that instead.
How to make a decision matrix with AI
It needs the full details of each option. The plan page, the quote or the offer email, pasted in or uploaded as a screenshot.
- Paste the prompt into a new chat.
- Answer what you’re deciding and what a good result looks like.
- Say what’s non-negotiable, for example a top budget, a finish date or something every option has to have.
- Say what matters most after that.
- Paste or upload every option at once.
It then writes back your must-haves and a scorecard of 5 items, with a weight on each and a description of what scores a 1, a 3 and a 5. Nothing gets scored until you reply “go,” so you can change a weight before it counts.
The weighted decision matrix prompt
I have 2 or more options and I need help picking one. Don't score anything yet. Ask me these questions one at a time, and wait for each answer:
1. What are you deciding, and what does a good result look like to you?
2. What can't you budge on? For example a top budget, a finish date, or something every option has to have.
3. After those, what matters most to you? For example the lowest price, speed, the warranty, how well they communicate, or their reviews.
4. Please paste or upload the details of every option.
Step 1: show me you understood. Then stop.
Write back:
- The decision and what a good result looks like, in one sentence.
- My must-haves, as a numbered list. Only the ones I gave you in question 2.
- A scorecard of 5 things to judge the options on, built from my answers. Give each one a weight so the 5 add up to 100. For each one, say what a 1, a 3 and a 5 looks like for this decision. Write each 1, 3 and 5 so an option could earn it from what its details actually say.
- The name of each option you found, so I can check none are missing.
End with: "Reply go, or tell me what to change." Do no scoring until I reply go.
Step 2: after I reply go, compare the options in this order.
Line them up. Make a table of everything this decision needs, one row per item, one column per option. Mark each cell Included, Extra cost, Not included, or Not mentioned. Not mentioned never counts as included. Under the table, list what each option leaves out that I would still have to pay for or sort out. Don't guess a price for those. Write "ask them" instead.
Check the must-haves. Pass or fail for each option, with the reason. If it depends on something unknown, write "Pass if" and name it. An option that fails stays in the comparison, marked as failed.
Score. One table: each scorecard item, each option, a score from 1 to 5. Next to every score, copy the words from that option's details that earned it. If the details say nothing about it, write "?" and add it to the questions at the end instead of guessing.
Score against the 1, 3 and 5 you wrote, not against a perfect option. These are real options, and I have to pick one of them.
Do the math. Show weight times score for each line, then each option's total out of 500.
Warnings. Anything in an option's own details that should worry me, for example a large deposit up front or a price that can change later. Copy the line. Warnings cover only what the details say. Missing items are already listed above. If there is nothing, write "None."
Pick. Name the winner and the runner-up. Say what would have to change for the runner-up to win.
If every option fails a must-have, say so plainly, then name the one that comes closest and what to ask them to fix.
Questions to ask before I decide. Up to 3 for each option, starting with the "?" scores and the "ask them" items.
Why it works: It shows you the scorecard and waits for your go before it scores anything, so the options get judged on what you care about. Next to every score, it copies the line from the option that earned it, so you can check its work.
One gap: If you paste in just the prices, it scores just the prices. The fees, the contract and the fine print are where options usually fall apart.
Simple fix: Paste the whole offer, fine print included. When the fine print runs past a page, turn on thinking or reasoning, or use one of the stronger models, so it reads all of it.
Decision matrix example: 3 roofing quotes scored
This is the result from a test run in ChatGPT with 3 made-up roofing quotes. The budget was $16,000, the roof had to be done by December 15, and every quote needed a full tear-off and a permit.
| Quote | Price | Must-haves | Total out of 500 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quote 1 | $14,800 | Passed all 4 | 380 |
| Quote 2 | $11,200 | Failed 3 | 200 |
| Quote 3 | $16,900 | Failed 2 | 290 |
The cheapest quote came last. It never mentioned a permit, a tear-off or a start date, and the prompt marked those “Not mentioned” instead of assuming they were included. It also flagged the 50% deposit and the $95-per-sheet charge for rotted decking as warnings.
The same check works on anything with hidden costs, like the moving costs prompt does for a move.
4 AI prompt tips that stop it from guessing
Each tip is a line from the prompt above. Copy the line into your own prompts.
1. Add guardrails so AI sticks to your rules
My must-haves, as a numbered list. Only the ones I gave you in question 2.
Without this line, AI adds must-haves of its own. In one test it turned “steady video calls” from a priority into a must-have, then marked every option “Pass if” on it. This line keeps your list as yours. It works in any prompt where you set the rules, for example a budget or a trip plan.
2. Write a scoring rubric AI can actually use
Write each 1, 3 and 5 so an option could earn it from what its details actually say.
AI likes to set a top score that nothing on paper can reach, like “strong evidence of stable speeds” for an internet plan. Then your most important item can’t tell the options apart. This line ties every score to something an option can actually show. It’s worth adding to any scorecard or grading prompt.
3. Stop AI from assuming what a document leaves out
Not mentioned never counts as included.
AI tends to give an option the benefit of the doubt and fill the gap with what it expects, a quiet kind of AI hallucination. This line makes it treat silence as a question, so a quote that never mentions a permit doesn’t get credit for one. Use it whenever AI compares documents, for example 2 contracts or 2 insurance plans.
4. Make AI check the plan with you first
Do no scoring until I reply go.
A pause before the real work lets you fix the plan while it’s cheap. Here, you can change a weight before a single option gets scored. Add it to any prompt that builds something long, for example a trip plan or a report outline.
Related prompt: the hard decision prompt argues against the option you’re leaning toward, for choices that come down to your gut.